Who would you give up for Bobby Ryan?

[NYRAvery16NYR]

I got this from another board, but I know many of you {as well as myself} would love to have Bobby Ryan as a Ranger..

"Eric Duhatschek was just interviewed on TSN and said that Bobby Ryan might be in play (and that the Leafs were interested, which is no surprise given Burke's connection)."



So what do you think it would take for us to land Ryan, and would it be worth it?

[LyNX27]

Dolan

[nyr2417]

i'd say for us to get him they'd probably want something along the lines of grachev, girardi, #10 pick? I think that's pretty close

[aqsw]

Originally Posted by NYRAvery16NYR

I got this from another board, but I know many of you {as well as myself} would love to have Bobby Ryan as a Ranger..

"Eric Duhatschek was just interviewed on TSN and said that Bobby Ryan might be in play (and that the Leafs were interested, which is no surprise given Burke's connection)."



So what do you think it would take for us to land Ryan, and would it be worth it?

mdz and a 2nd

[nyr2417]

Originally Posted by aqsw

mdz and a 2nd

tempting

[jniklast]

Grachev, Gilroy and some picks

[GAGLine]

Whatever it would take, I'm not willing to give up.

[ecemleafs]

yeah id give up grachev, 10th pick, + sangs/gilroy

[hpNYR]

Originally Posted by nyr2417

tempting

MDZ and a 2nd is tempting? Not at all. I rather keep MDZ and the 2nd.

I like Bobby Ryan alot, but not for that. MDZ has too much potential to be a star.

Sanguinetti, Gilroy, & the 10th pick.

[HockeyGuy1985*]

Ehhhhh no.

[Jarkko Immonen]

Put Grachev and some other things and you've got a deal.

[Ih8theislanders]

Originally Posted by hpNYR

MDZ and a 2nd is tempting? Not at all. I rather keep MDZ and the 2nd.

I like Bobby Ryan alot, but not for that. MDZ has too much potential to be a star.

Sanguinetti, Gilroy, & the 10th pick.

Ryan is already a star. He's 23 and scored over 30 goals twice already. He played under 65 games last year I'm pretty sure and still scored 31.

[McMonster]

Originally Posted by nyr2417

i'd say for us to get him they'd probably want something along the lines of grachev, girardi, #10 pick? I think that's pretty close

not even close.

The deal would have to include a 1st round pick, top flight prospect, and a quality NHL player.

[hpNYR]

Originally Posted by Ih8theislanders

Ryan is already a star. He's 23 and scored over 30 goals twice already. He played under 65 games last year I'm pretty sure and still scored 31.

I'm aware. However, not for a player like MDZ playing a position in which great offensive d-men aren't all that often. When both reach their prime I think looking back at a trade like that you would say we overpaid by including a 2nd.I think an MDZ in his prime and a Bobby Ryan in his prime will be an even swap. That's how highly I think of MDZ, and that's why I don't make the trade.

On a side note. God forbid we let our homegrown players develop; and a future star like MDZ at that.

[Vitto79]

Grachev and Sanguinetti...........he's worth it

[broadwayblue]

What is Bobby Ryan's upside? He scored 35 last year in his second full year. Can he score 45+? He would sure fill in that 2nd line RW spot pretty nicely.

[N9Y4R]

Bobby Ryan is an absolute stud! It will cost a ****load to get him, a Kessel type of deal. Multiple players/prospect/picks...

too much is what it will cost.

[nyr2417]

Originally Posted by Vitto79

Grachev and Sanguinetti...........he's worth it

no they're not going to trade bobby ryan for 2 players who have barely sniffed the nhl. as i said i think grachev girardi and 10th overall might get it done

[Richter35]

2 1st's and a 2nd (sounds familiar...)

but not this year's if i could get away with it. I think he's worth it.

[h0ckeyman]

I would give up a lottttt for Bobby. He would an awesome addition to the ranger lineup.

[FOXHOUND*]

They need D so start with one of Sangs and McDonaugh

[Crazyhorse30]

No one in this organization is untouchable IMO, although there are obvious players we would not trade to for him, per se.

[TheHotRock]

for bobby ryan, there's no such thing as untouchable.

i wonder if mdz, grachev and a 1st would be enough.

i don't think the ducks would go for it.

[RangerFan10]

I'd give them almost anything...

I'd prefer to do it without giving up Staal or MDZ. Not sure if that's possible, however.

I'd easily give up Grachev, #10 pick, and Sangs/McD/Dubinsky/Anisimov/Stepan/Kreider (preferably not a Ani or Stepan, since we're pretty thin at center.) I think it COULD be enough, but they'd also probably get better offers.

[RangerFan10]

Originally Posted by FOXHOUND

They need D so start with one of Staal and Del Zotto

fixed.