Go Back   HFBoards > General Hockey Discussion > The History of Hockey
Mobile Hockey's Future Become a Sponsor Site Rules Support Forum vBookie

The History of Hockey Relive great moments in hockey history and discuss how the game has changed over time.

GVT and Goaltending

Thread Tools
08-18-2010, 08:11 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 20
vCash: 500
GVT and Goaltending

GVT pt.1, pt.2, pt.3, download link.

When analyzing goaltenders uniquely GVT seems to paint an accurate picture when compared to canonically assumed knowledge. (It seems less accurate for forwards and unreliable for defensemen.)

The general gist of the statistic is goals prevented compared to a replacement goalie (slightly below average goalie). Related to save percentage, but there are some differences between the two statistics.

(I don't know what those random letter combinations mean either. GVT is the only stat I looked at. I do know SGVT is shootout GVT and is therefore useless and included in the final GVT.)

I don't think it's schedule adjusted unfortunately. Less important for regular season numbers, but significant for playoff numbers, so when analyzing playoff numbers I multiplied by a factor of:
<1967-68 (2x)
1967-68 -> 1973-74 (4/3x)
1974-75 -> 1985-86 (27/24x)
>1986-87 (1x)

Some sanity tests:
- Hasek is the greatest regular season goalie of all time. His playoff record while decent is comparable to quite a few other goalies (Parent, Brodeur, Belfour, etc.).
- Plante is arguably both the second best regular season and playoff goalie.
- Roy is the second best regular season goalie of his era, but there are a good number of comparable goalies historically. (Plante, Hall, T. Esposito). He's probably the greatest playoff goalie ever, where his average run during a 15 year period would be similar to Fuhr's cup winning numbers.
- Sawchuk has the greatest playoff run ever. A very good peak, but little else.
- Giguere's 2003 playoff run is one of the greatest in recent memory, and perhaps the best by a losing goaltender.
- Smith was an excellent playoff goalie.
- Osgood was an above average goaltender but not much else. He does have 2 very good playoff performances though.
- It seems to do a fairly accurate job of estimating 1st and 2nd All-Star Teams from the mid 50s to the mid 60s, except it suggests Bower got shortchanged quite a bit in this regard. (The top 100 list seems to agree with this assessment.)

Oddities (or maybe not):
- Durnan's numbers approach Hasek's, which would seem to be justified by his 6 1st team all-stars in 7 years. Maybe he should get more credit? Doesn't have the greatest playoff resume, but it's not that much worse than Hasek's. Extremely short career though.
- Hall doesn't seem to do as well as one would expect. He does consistently well throughout his career for the most part but never seems to as dominant as one would expect from a player with so many All-Star Team placements. (His numbers are still very good)
- Esposito fares exceedingly well during the regular season. Not sure if this should be the case, but if I had to guess poor competition might be the cause.
- Brodeur doesn't perform 'well' by this metric (goalies are being given some credit for influencing shot totals). He has some great seasons but suffers from inconsistency.
- Belfour comes out nicely in comparison a worse regular season goalie than Brodeur, but a better playoff one (arguably).
- Fuhr may be overrated in comparison to other dynasty goalies and some modern goaltenders. Quite arguably still a top 10 playoff goalie using this metric.

Goalies in top 100 list who have missing years:
- Tretiak (all)
- Gardiner (all)
- Brimsek (first half)
- Broda (first half)

Following placements were eyeballed. Prime (consistently great) and peak (consistently amazing for consecutive years) were weakly defined.

7 Best prime regular season goalies (~10 consecutive years):
1) Hasek
2) Esposito
3) Plante
4) Roy
5) Hall
6) Durnan
7) Sawchuk

7 Best peak regular season goalies (~5 consecutive years):
1) Hasek
2) Durnan
3) Sawchuk
4) Parent
5) Plante
6) Dryden
7) Esposito

7 Best prime playoff goalies* (~5 consecutive):
1) Roy
2) Plante
3) Dryden
4) Smith
5) Belfour**
6) Broda***
7) Bower
* Some will notice that these are mostly dynasty goalies. This shouldn't be surprising as they would have to be consistently great to win multiple Stanley Cups in a row.
** Belfour's excellent 5 year run was done on 2 separate teams, which makes it particularly impressive. (He did miss the playoffs once in-between though, but in his defense he was traded to the 2nd worst team in the league, however he did play poorly that year.)
*** Could very well be higher. His individual numbers most likely wouldn't be any higher than Belfour's, Smith's or Dryden's, but might make up for it in greater consistency over a longer period of time. He also lost some of his best years to the war.

7 Best peak playoff goalies (~2 consecutive years):
1) Bower
2) Plante
3) Roy*
4) Sawchuk
5) Parent
6) Brodeur
7) Hasek
*Roy never really had great consecutive years but he had so many you can't really put him any lower.

22 Best Playoff Performances*:
1) 6.8 GVT/series: Sawchuk 51-52
2) 5.925 GVT/series: Giguere 02-03
3) 5.55 GVT/series: Bower 62-63
4) 4.7 GVT/series: Roy 92-93
5) 4.6 GVT/series: Parent 73-74
6) 4.575 GVT/series: McLean 93-94
7) 4.5 GVT/series: Roy 00-01
8) 4.45 GVT/series: Bower 63-64
9) 4.4 GVT/series: Plante 56-57
10) 4.4 GVT/series: Esposito 70-71
11) 4.25 GVT/series: Plante 57-58
12) 4.225 GVT/series: Hasek 98-99
13) 3.875 GVT/series: Brodeur 94-95
14) 3.85 GVT/series: Roy 85-86
15) 3.75 GVT/series: Brodeur 02-03
16) 3.675 GVT/series: Ranford 89-90
17) 3.65 GVT/series: Hall 60-61
18) 3.525 GVT/series: Smith 82-83
19) 3.5 GVT/series: Roy 88-89
20) 3.4875 GVT/series: Dryden 76-77
21) 3.4 GVT/series: Belfour 98-99
22) 3.37 GVT/series: Plante 68-69
* Might have missed a few. Smythe winners + McLean were the only 'average' goalies I checked.

Last edited by Snowl: 08-19-2010 at 05:17 AM.
Snowl is offline   Reply With Quote
08-18-2010, 10:49 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 3,994
vCash: 500
By GVT, Hasek's regular season peak is comparable to any player in history, up there with Orr and Gretzky. That's a bit higher than Hasek is usually rated around here, but I'm not sure that it's wrong. It's why I had Hasek at #5 on the latest round of the HOH top-100 (although I didn't use GVT to get there.)

I would say Hasek has some separation over Durnan in GVT. While Durnan has the biggest single year of the two, it was a war year. And Hasek is well ahead in his 2nd best, 3rd best, etc seasons. Also, the thing about Durnan's numbers is that there are no shot counts available before 1952-53 (the current earliest season that the Hockey Summary Project). And I'm not sure if GVT uses the HSP data or not, so goalie GVT data may not include save percentage for some post-1953 years also. I don't know what assumptions GVT makes in separating team defence from goaltender performance in the pre-save percentage era, so Durnan may be getting some credit for team defence.

A note on Brodeur's playoffs - playoff GVT, unlike regular season GVT, does not include shot prevention credit. (Possibly because there are often no backup goalie numbers to compare to). So it's likely that Brodeur's playoff GVT underestimates him in this area, along with other strong puckhandlers, including Belfour.

If you look at two-year peak, regular season and playoffs, Bernie Parent's 73-74 and 74-75 are neck-and-neck with Dominik Hasek's 97-98 and 98-99.

Edit: I did a little more digging in the file. It appears that recorded SV% from 1955-67 is used, but not from 1968-82, or pre-1955. This means that GVT may underestimate Bernie Parent's peak! It estimates his SV% was 0.927 in 73-74 and 0.918 in 74-75. In fact, his recorded SV% were 0.933 and 0.924 for those years. Although I'm not sure what GVT estimated for the league averages, it's possible it was low on everyone's SV%.

Last edited by overpass: 08-19-2010 at 12:14 AM.
overpass is offline   Reply With Quote
08-18-2010, 11:52 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Halifax
Country: Japan
Posts: 30,337
vCash: 500
Look at rookie go! If we're honest, that's one of the better initial 10 post posts by a noob on these boards in quite a while.

Ohashi_Jouzu* is offline   Reply With Quote
08-19-2010, 12:01 AM
Registered User
BostonAJ's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Southie
Country: United States
Posts: 2,559
vCash: 500
Great info. Makes me wonder if Tony Esposito is well underrated around here. His playoff performances may be underwhelming, but as a regular season goalie he looks outstanding.

BostonAJ is offline   Reply With Quote

Forum Jump


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:57 AM.

monitoring_string = "e4251c93e2ba248d29da988d93bf5144"

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com is a property of CraveOnline Media, LLC, an Evolve Media, LLC company. @2017 All Rights Reserved.