And I still stand by that Dukey would be better off staying in LSL for another year. He probs get 30 points this year, depending on how hard he works.
So Duclair is not physically strong enough...so you would have send Charles Hudon back in midget AAA last yr ? How many 16yo come in the league who are physically mature ? not many..
Duclair need to be challenge same with Drouin. One his making a great decision the other not so much (developpement wise)
So Duclair is not physically strong enough...so you would have send Charles Hudon back in midget AAA last yr ? How many 16yo come in the league who are physically mature ? not many..
Duclair need to be challenge same with Drouin. One his making a great decision the other not so
much (developpement wise)
Mike Matheson stayed in LSL and he's better then any D the Remparts have so what's your point ?
Does Duclair need the challenge ?
Yes probably, he will survive but I'd be shocked if he lit it up. 30G 20A and 100PIM, that's my prediction, he's tall enough to survive.
As for Drouin, oh boy, the kid is thin, and inconsistent. I'm not sure that going to Halifax is the smartest idea, IMO Drouin is better then Duclair but not as consistent.
The Lions are the 3rd best AAA team in Canada, so clearly they know what they're doing.
Mike Matheson stayed in LSL and he's better then any D the Remparts have so what's your point ?
Does Duclair need the challenge ?
Yes probably, he will survive but I'd be shocked if he lit it up. 30G 20A and 100PIM, that's my prediction, he's tall enough to survive.
As for Drouin, oh boy, the kid is thin, and inconsistent. I'm not sure that going to Halifax is the smartest idea, IMO Drouin is better then Duclair but not as consistent.
The Lions are the 3rd best AAA team in Canada, so clearly they know what they're doing.
At this moment, Lefebvre is better than Matheson.
If you dominated in the previous league you played in, why go back there?
Going to Halifax is the best option, it doesn't mean it would be a complete mistake to go back to LSL though. And Matheson went back there because he had no other options. He probably would have played in a better league if he had had the option.
Last edited by SergeConstantin74: 08-20-2011 at 04:47 PM.
Duclair with three assists and Erne with a goal and an assist through two periods; pretty solid debut for the kids.
Looks like I'm going to have to try to go the pre-season game in Ottawa to see them in action.
If you dominated in the previous league you played in, why go back there?
Going to Halifax is the best option, it doesn't mean it would be a complete mistake to go back to
LSL though. And Matheson went back there because he had no other options. He probably would have played in a better league if he had had the option.
1 I don't think so about Lefevbre being better then Matheson.
2 They dominated at TIMES. Especially during the playoffs lol.
3 Matheson had options, Shawi was one of them, as was Junior AAA in Vaudreuil which isn't far from Point-Claire.
4 I concede that they don't have anything to prove. But I'd like to see Drouin iron out his consistency issues, an Duclair his temper issues.
Lefebvre is definitely better. You're talking about one of the best d-man in the Q and a 19 yo veteran who just came back from Team Canada's camp...
Matheson couldn't play for Shawi if he wanted to keep his NCAA eligibility and 16 years old in the JAAA???
Your talking about Matheson one of the best draft prospects and a WJC U-18 gold, he has a good chance to be a first rounder this year.
A 16 year Junior AAA it's possible, you said he has no options. He also could have gone to prep school or Dubuque early.
IMO he would junior just not in Shawi or in BC ( he almost wound up there).
He most likely wanted to graduate at John Rennie ( One of the Schools most lions players go to) with his friends. And no offence but there's more to do on the West Island then there is in Shawinigan.
Your talking about Matheson one of the best draft prospects and a WJC U-18 gold, he has a good chance to be a first rounder this year.
A 16 year Junior AAA it's possible, you said he has no options. He also could have gone to prep school or Dubuque early.
IMO he would junior just not in Shawi or in BC ( he almost wound up there).
He most likely wanted to graduate at John Rennie ( One of the Schools most lions players go to) with his friends. And no offence but there's more to do on the West Island then there is in Shawinigan.
I really don't care about Shawi, Matheson, the West Island, etc... and BTW, 16 yo CAN'T play in JAAA.
All I'm saying is that at the moment, Lefebvre is better. Anyway, we won't agree on this, so we should just let it go.
Last edited by SergeConstantin74: 08-21-2011 at 07:09 AM.
Any word yet on the arrival of Grigorenko?
Would be awesome to have another great talent in the CHL?
Do you know if he will show? Same with Kamaev who was drafted by the Huskies?
Does anyone here know about Vlad Shalimov too...so little info on him, apart from that he bagged a hatrick last night for Val Dor.
Has anyone ever seen the elusive Vlad?
lol
