Most Overrated Current: Ryan Shannon, Erik Karlsson (at the moment), Christer Olsson (lol)
All-Time: Mike Fisher, Chris Kelly
Most Underrated Current: Jason Spezza, Cody Bass, Erik Karlsson (futre prognostication)
All-Time: Dean McAmmond, Shean Donovan, Pavol Demitra
The Karlsson name on both lists? Simple. I feel looking at his defensive shortcoming, significant shortcomings...he is overrated right now. Looking at people selling him short I think in 5 years time he could be our franchise player.
most overrated: Karlsson - somehow he gets a pass on not being able to play defence
most underated: Michalek - The only time he didn't play well was when he could barely skate.
These choices are based on impressions from this board, and the fact that Karlsson has been anointed the second coming, and Michalek is some "old" guy that can be replaced, most likely by some guy who has never proved himself in the NHL.