Proposal: Montreal - Atlanta/Winnepeg

[Habiton]

From Montreal:
Andrei Kostitsyn
Yannick Weber

From Atlanta/Winnipeg:
Evander Kane

Kostitsyn is a 20 Goal Scorer and Weber could be a great offensive defensemen.

Evander Kane would be the perfect compliment for Pleks and Cammy. I know everyone here hates AK, but the reality is that he is a great player. Lead the Canadiens in hitting, got much better defensively, and with a good coach I think he could hit 60-70 points.

Is that fair? Add a pick or two?

[GoofSlashFoig]

If you want Kane, it's gonna involve Subban or Price going back the other way.

[jmor]

No way Winnipeg trades Kane. Young kid with only one season of NHL hockey under his belt.

Bogosian might be a different story though, because of his development and rumors about his dis-interest in coming to Winnipeg.

but hey, we'll see.

[caley]

This is a borderline 'Lock Thread' proposal for me, as in, it's really not even close. I'll let it linger for a bit but OP needs to overhaul that proposal.

[JVR21]

Brutal. And it is officially Winnipeg.

[HossTheBoss]

I honestly don't get it.

If Weber is so great, and holds so much value to Habs fans (as in, he's in every single proposal, including those which involve higher end players and great prospects) why not just keep him?

[LeafsFan2342]

This is the problem with Montreal fans, they think their players are so valuable

[Philadelphia Ducks]

No way Winnipeg would ever accept this. You're giving them an RFA and a prospect for one of their best players O.O. You'd definitely have to add picks and better prospects assuming Winnipeg even wants to do a total rebuild and farm selling all their roster players.

[exporta]

This is absolutely brutal.

This offer is easily trumped by any team in the NHL, and Kane isn't going anywhere.

[Dirty Danglez]

Its crazy how so many habsfans create these threads and think they are actually even close to fair value. I'm sorry lol.

[Habiton]

Apparently its real bad. Close it up, sorry.

[broc]

Originally Posted by Habiton

From Montreal:
Andrei Kostitsyn
Yannick Weber

From Atlanta/Winnipeg:
Evander Kane

Kostitsyn is a 20 Goal Scorer and Weber could be a great offensive defensemen.

Evander Kane would be the perfect compliment for Pleks and Cammy. I know everyone here hates AK, but the reality is that he is a great player. Lead the Canadiens in hitting, got much better defensively, and with a good coach I think he could hit 60-70 points.

Is that fair? Add a pick or two?

Is that fair? LOL.
Just LOL dude.

Counter:

Eric O'Dell
Ron Hainsey

for

PK Subban

[broc]

Please, yes... lock this thread

OP should be banned for creating topics for a week for this filth

[Habs Fan In Ottawa*]

You're the reason us habs fans are a laughing stock in the trade proposal forum. Just stop. Evander Kane >>>>>>>>> Kostitsyn + Webber

[Jeffrey]

Ok let's make another stab with Evander but different habs players:

Max Pacioretty, Danny Kristo, 1st pick 2011 draft(17th overall)

for

Evander Kane

better ?? not enough ?

[broc]

Originally Posted by Jeffrey

Ok let's make another stab with Evander but different habs players:

Max Pacioretty, Danny Kristo, 1st pick 2011 draft(17th overall)

for

Evander Kane

better ?? not enough ?

Not enough.
To be honest, MTL doesn't have the quality of prospects/picks in its system to make a serious pitch for what it will take to get Kane.

And who knows how MaxPac responds to that injury..