The David Poile Roster Move Game

[I Will Son]

hahaha that brawl was epic. Who was picked with the first we traded for him? (Witt)

[token grinder]

Originally Posted by I Will Son

hahaha that brawl was epic. Who was picked with the first we traded for him? (Witt)

varlamov of the caps

bad roster move: dumont contract

[I Will Son]

Originally Posted by token grinder

varlamov of the caps

bad roster move: dumont contract

Not a bad pick

Good move: Signing Marcel Goc

[gopreds19]

Originally Posted by I Will Son

Not a bad pick

Good move: Signing Marcel Goc

Wasting a 1st on Chet Pickard.

[PredsV82]

getting a 2nd(now Hellberg) and Halischuk for a washed up Arnott

[I Will Son]

Originally Posted by gopreds19

Wasting a 1st on Chet Pickard.

edit I got beat


The forsberg deal was kinda bad, even though we got everything back just about

[PredsV82]

Originally Posted by I Will Son

Hornqvist as the last pick

I think this was used earlier

edit: yes, actually was cited in the first post of the thread

[I Will Son]

Originally Posted by PredsV82

I think this was used earlier

edit: yes, actually was cited in the first post of the thread

ha sry i didnt read much of first page. Im not in the right mind set at the moment any way. I hope know one said what i just changed my last post to.... bleh

[gopreds19]

So are we on bad or good now?

[gopreds19]

Originally Posted by gopreds19

So are we on bad or good now?

We'll go good, drafting Erat late in the draft (7th round?)

[BigFatCat999]

A good: drafted patric hornquist dead last in the draft.

Bad: Picked Brian Finley with the 6th overall pick in the 1999 draft.

Good: Traded for Steve Sullivan in 03 04.

Bad: Brendan Witt

Good: Drafted Ryan Suter ahead of higher ranked guys like Dion Phaneuf and Brayden Coburn

Bad: Josef Vasichuk

Good: Thomas Vokoun from the Canadiens

Bad: Ronning for The Drunk defenseman whose name escapes me. And then I just remembered, Karlahti.

Good: Jan Hlavac for a 7th.../ Pekka Friggin Rinne


Bad: Vitali Vishnevsky

Shea Weber in the 2nd round (good)

No value received for Peverley (bad).

Good: Getting a 1st round pick back from Philly for the rights to Timonen and Hartnell and having that pick become Blum. (2 goods in one fail swoop)

Bad: Mark Mowers

Good: Is Poile the one who hired Trotz? If so, that for good.

Bad: bad roster move: dumont contract

Good move: Signing Marcel Goc

Bad: Wasting a 1st on Chet Pickard.

Good: getting a 2nd(now Hellberg) and Halischuk for a washed up Arnott/ We'll go good, drafting Erat late in the draft (7th round?)

[PredsV82]

so we actually need two "bads" to be back on track...

I'll throw out wasting a second on grebeshkov for one...

[Adz]

Good--Signing Kariya

[Paranoid Android]

Originally Posted by PredsV82

so we actually need two "bads" to be back on track...

I'll throw out wasting a second on grebeshkov for one...

I thought that move was awesome personally.... just bad luck that he got a freakish injury

[PredsV82]

Originally Posted by Paranoid Android

I thought that move was awesome personally.... just bad luck that he got a freakish injury

it was bad to trade for an RFA that was signed to a contract too big to qualify and thus retain his rights.

poile paid "asset" price for a "rental"


and just to get us back on track I'll throw out the entire 2000 draft after Hartnell... 11 picks, ZERO NHL players(Pivko got ONE game with the Preds, otherwise complete bupkus)

[Paranoid Android]

Originally Posted by PredsV82

it was bad to trade for an RFA that was signed to a contract too big to qualify and thus retain his rights.

poile paid "asset" price for a "rental"


and just to get us back on track I'll throw out the entire 2000 draft after Hartnell... 11 picks, ZERO NHL players(Pivko got ONE game with the Preds, otherwise complete bupkus)

The price was completely fine as a rental... him being RFA was just a bonus that we decided not to utilize.

We can let it count though

We are on bad now right? May as well throw Lombardi out there

[Viqsi]

Good: The Sergei Kostitsyn experiment.

[Enoch]

I'm going to double up to get my rinne post back in.

Bad - 1 year contract offer to pending free agent Scott Hartnell
Good - Pekka Rinne - 8th round 258th overall.

[kypredsfan]

Good - atleast for me, Radek Bonk

[Predatorbill]

Bad trading TV and how it was done. I know that Liarpold made him do it.

[kypredsfan]

Originally Posted by Predatorbill

Bad trading TV and how it was done. I know that Liarpold made him do it.

That was a terrible day indeed when they announced trading him.

[PredsV82]

cant blame poile for Vokoun.

he got as much as he could for him.

good: Vladimir Orszagh

[worstfaceoffmanever]

Bad - Talking about making a major signing on July 1, 2010... only for it to end up being Jonas Andersson, who didn't even make it out of training camp before getting dealt to Vancouver and, after a brief stint with Manitoba, returning to Europe.

[SLake]

Originally Posted by worstfaceoffmanever

Bad - Talking about making a major signing on July 1, 2010... only for it to end up being Jonas Andersson, who didn't even make it out of training camp before getting dealt to Vancouver and, after a brief stint with Manitoba, returning to Europe.

Good - Turning that signing into Shane O'Brien before training camp ended.

[token grinder]

could that july 1 signing been lombardi, but was held up a day or two?



anyway-bad-keeping marek zidlicky around long enough for my kid to come out of the womb yelling GDit zidlicky!