Not a 1st, We are talking Joseph Labate and a 2nd territory. A player needs to be a high calibre defenceman for a 1st or someone that could put significant points on the board.
People like Neiler as a person which changes his perception of value. That being said he has been a cornerstone in the community which would be the ONLY reason that would keep us from dealing him. he is 32 and the style he plays will lead him to start gradually slowing down. I would be in favor of moving him to a cup contender.