Could really use some strategy advice!

[slap shot 99]

In a 10 team keeper league with a 25 man roster (12F, 6 D, 4 Bench, 3 G) with the following categories: G, A, P, PPG, PPA, GWG, PIM, +/-, SOG, W, GAA, and SV%.

I have to make a decision in terms of strategy to take at the draft and could really use some help. Right now my 2 keeper goalies going into the draft are rinne and thomas. Based on what is available it looks like I have 2 ways that I could go with my draft pick. So which combination of players would you rather have:

1) luongo + Nash + one of sharp or d. roy

or

2) Halak + Malkin + one of hemsky or cammalleri

Really the debate is whether to basically ensure my dominance in the goalie categories or take a little bit of a hit to improve my scoring. What do you think?
Thanks

[NYR89]

I'd go the Luongo route because he'll rack up the W's that Rinne is going to miss. Plus Nash should have a good year with Carter.